Sheriff Executes Warrant In Alleged Fraud Ring

Sheriff Executes Warrant In Alleged Fraud Ring

NBC 4

Law-enforcement officials say they may have broken up an elaborate fraud ring involving hundreds of allegedly stolen vehicles.

» 7 Comments | Post a Comment

BALTIMORE, Ohio —Law-enforcement officials in one Central Ohio community believe they may have broken up an elaborate fraud ring involving hundreds of allegedly stolen vehicles.

NBC 4 reported with the FAST FACTS.
Fairfield County sheriff’s deputies executed a search warrant on 50 vehicles in a field at 2630 Musser Rd. in Baltimore in Walnut Township Monday morning.

Investigators said the vehicles are part of a fraud ring and 100 additional vehicles could be involved.

The investigation began last week when a deputy stopped a vehicle with a fictitious dealer plate. It was discovered the Lancaster dealership was no longer in business and the driver could not prove ownership of the vehicle.

While questioning the driver, it was discovered that he had more than 50 other cars parked on his property.

Detectives were able trace back the vehicle VIN numbers to determine the alleged crime.

Pataskala auto-sales business Sommer Auto, Inc., at 15 W. Broad St., Pataskala, sold individual cars and collected payments but didn’t pay the lender, according to Fairfield County Sheriff Dave Phalen.

Legitimate customers purchased a vehicle and made their payment to Sommer Auto, but Sommer Auto would pocket the money and not pay the creditor. The bank issued a repossession order. Sommer Auto repossessed the vehicle and hid it from the lender, telling the lender the auto wasn’t found, according to authorities.

Sommer Auto also took in trade-ins and did not pay off the customers’ loans. The business hid the vehicle, and when the lender came looking for the vehicle, Sommer Auto told the lender it never had the vehicle, according to authorities.

An agent for Sommer Auto fraudulently removed the lien holders from the titles and resold the vehicles, Phalen said.

Phalen said the operation was an elaborate scheme to defraud the banks and the sheriff’s office thinks the scheme continued for a year and there could be hundreds of victims.

“We confirmed ownership with some of the lenders and also confirmed that they had been looking for these vehicles,“ Phalen said.

Many of the vehicles will be turned directly over to the banks who own them. The others will be impounded until the proper owners can be found, according to Phalen.

Phalen said the alleged fraud took place outside of Fairfield County, so the investigation will be turned over to other investigators with the State Highway Patrol theft section and Licking County.

NBC 4 tried to contact Sommer Auto, Inc. A manager we spoke to denied having knowledge on the investigation.

No charges were filed, but the sheriff’s office expected to file charges in the future.

For additional information on this developing story, stay with NBC 4 and refresh nbc4i.com—Where Accuracy Matters.
To submit a story idea or news tip, e-mail .
MORE: NBC 4 Local News | Local Crime News
NBC 4 SPORTS: Sports News, Video
NBC 4 POLITICS: Headlines, Interactives & Video

Advertisement

 
View More: sommer auto,fraud,fairfield county sheriff's office,baltimore,
Not what you're looking for? Try our quick search:
 

Advertisement

Reader Reactions

Flag Comment Posted by shellsmith on November 28, 2009 at 10:11 am

I would suggest checking your title and make sure Sommer Auto is the lien holder and noone else. I would get ahold of Tim Hughes. (BMV investigator for fraud)  I have contacted him and he was very helpful.

Flag Comment Posted by DERBYGAL13912 on November 28, 2009 at 3:10 am

WHAT DO I DO? I HAVE A CAR THROUGH THEM THAT I HAVE HAD FOR A YEAR AND A HALF. CAN ANYONE PLEASE TELL ME I LIVE 2 HOURS AWAY THANKS SO MUCH

Flag Comment Posted by Buckeyefan222 on November 24, 2009 at 7:25 am

I have been fighting with the finacial company and sommers auto..they took my car last january..I still continue getting letters from mongoose saying i never made a payment..and i talked to kelly the owner of sommers auto a month ago and of course he was still apologizing and of course nothing he can do about it..I just want justice and this proves that there will be..I just want to know if there is something more we can do like get our money back or at least the cars back..ahh prob not..

Flag Comment Posted by SFisher on November 23, 2009 at 7:13 pm

Not that they are all bad, but this is one very good reason to never do a “buy here pay here” deal.  If you can’t pay for the vehicle outright come to the lot with your own financing pre-approved by the lender of your choice.

This is a similar situation to apartment communities that have the tenants pay their utilities to them and then they pay the companies.  If they neglect to pay the tenant loses the service.  I would never rent from a place where the utilities were not in my own name.

Flag Comment Posted by shellsmith on November 23, 2009 at 6:46 pm

I am one of their “victims” I had to return my truck to Sommer when Mongoose came around looking to repo it.  I saw the news tonight and there it was my truck they make me so pissy

Flag Comment Posted by OmBass on November 23, 2009 at 6:12 pm

Agreed.  And as the illustrious Bob Barker would say, please have your crooks spayed and neutered.

Flag Comment Posted by Patriots on November 23, 2009 at 11:55 am

If these shmucks would have put half that munch brain effort into running a legit business they might still be in business today and making a profit. But instead they spent all this time and effort into scamming people it will cost them hopefully quite a bit of time in jail. Good riddens!

Post a Comment(Requires free registration)

  • Please avoid offensive, vulgar, or hateful language.
  • Respect others.
  • Use the "Flag Comment" link when necessary.
  • See the Terms and Conditions for details.
Click here to post a comment.

 

Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement

Consumer Info & Money Saving Tips

Advertisement